Father-Son or Brother-Brother stories

[musclegod300]

Just wondering how many of you are turned on by Dad on Son, Or Bro on Bro Stories.

[agreatguy6]

Well, the way I see it, in a COMIC, it's ignorable, as long as they don't mention it too much. Like in "My Raunchy Son" or whatever its called. Then you're only reading it for sex, not because its incest (or at least that's why I read it).

But in Fiction, you can't really forget that, and it's QUITE disgusting if it's good fiction, because good fiction doesn't let you forget things like that.

[inflated]

Originally Posted by musclegod300

Just Wondering Who Likes Incest? (Not In Real Life Ew.. But n stories haha)

No, No, No----Creepy and not interesting

[agreatguy6]

I agree, it IS disgusting, and anyone who likes it most likely is a tad bit unstable.
I would suggest a psychologist.


And suddenly, the subject changes...

[musclegod300]

What you guys gotta say about it now :P

[WorshipMuscle]

Hey Dude!
You're right. We've been reading your stories and based on the numerous comments that I see posted.......seems we can't get enough of them.....and the last time I checked, quite a lot of them involve some older Bro turned on by his younger Bro and a Bro muscling it up with his Dad. Keep write them Bro, they are in heavy demand!

[jsmith2300]

Well, it's a tough call. On the one hand, brother-brother stories hit so close to home since I have a brother and can see where that attraction comes in sometimes (jealousy over size, etc). With Dad-son stories, I think the attraction comes in for me when a son outgrows his father and shows off. Kind of saying how his genetics are superior and showing how their roles have shifted in the son's favor. So, for me, that's hot. I say if you are looking to do one, go for it. We have a lot of brother stories. Son-father we don't see often. I'd just be careful with the sex is all.

--JSmith

[TheMM]

Originally Posted by musclegod300

What you guys gotta say about it now :P

What do you mean by that? I mean, by the way you put that, it sounds kinda like...a taunt.

[ottm]

Yo mg300, if you're hinting about incest in Chap 6 of your current tale...
THEN GO FOR IT!! Let Wes fuck Bren into unconsciousness.

[benchdude]

Originally Posted by musclegod300

What you guys gotta say about it now :P

nope, still just as sick and disgusting as it's always been, and you're definitely in need of help. that topic has no place at all on this board, it has absolutely nothing to do with muscle growth. and that stupid remark you just made makes it look like you're saying "haha all of you who thought it was sick before are just as turned on by it as I am", as if you're actually trying to recruit people on to your side to get into it. that is really sick, and pathetic.

[musclegod300]

"If you don't have anything nice to say, Don't say anything at all"

[BigLittleTim]

Big Bro physically beating up and dominating his Little Bro... that's HOT. Don't think there has to be a sexual component to it, though. It's just enough to show the comparison of BIG vs. small; powerful vs. powerless; muscular vs. puny; etc. Everything doesn't have to turn into a blue film.

[jerseyflex]

No way do i like the sexual side but I do like the bully older brother torturing the little brother. then the little brother hits a growth spurt and gets significantly bigger and stronger than the older brother (or the "not so bi big brother!!") and the tables turn. the thought of the younger brother exacting his revenge through physical domination of the smaller older brother......

i did witness a younger brother who was a full foot taller than his older brother and very muscular pick up his brother and tossed him then hung him by his rear belt loop on a hook. (the older brothers feet were dangling in the air.) the whole scene started when the little bro got mad telling a story from their childhood about getting caught with playboy magazines because the older bro told their parents and little bro got in trouble. little bro stood up and said "this is for destroying my stash" then proceeded.....everyone was drunk and laughing like hell. cant imagine how humiliating and frustrating it must have been for the older bro.

[trax29]

Wow, who knew this would be such a hot-button topic....?

Benchdude, for this being a fantasy-type site, I think you're getting a little too mean in your response to a fairly simple question. MG300 didn't ask what your religious or moral convictions were. He simply asked what people thought of it in relation to stories he writes and if anyone would like to see him add that element.

At least that's how I understood his question...


I agree with you that in reality incest is not my cup of tea, but in the land of make-believe I could see it happen. I mean who hasn't seen hot twin brothers and had a bit of an evil thought of what they'd do with them in bed.

In any case, a simple, "No Incest (even fantasy) please" would have been sufficient. You didn't need to be rude about it.

[chocomus]

Originally Posted by trax29

Wow, who knew this would be such a hot-button topic....?

Benchdude, for this being a fantasy-type site, I think you're getting a little too mean in your response to a fairly simple question. MG300 didn't ask what your religious or moral convictions were. He simply asked what people thought of it in relation to stories he writes and if anyone would like to see him add that element.

At least that's how I understood his question...


I agree with you that in reality incest is not my cup of tea, but in the land of make-believe I could see it happen. I mean who hasn't seen hot twin brothers and had a bit of an evil thought of what they'd do with them in bed.

In any case, a simple, "No Incest (even fantasy) please" would have been sufficient. You didn't need to be rude about it.

True! Those kind of comments are what make nice and good artist/writers leave the site. I get so mad at those kind of people... We're not here to judge anyone and i'm sure we can give our opinion without being rude or mean.

All those thing he said that mg300 was insinuating... "recruiting"... where does he take them from? Maybe if it was that guy the one who mention them, he should be the one needing his head checked out. Paranoid... *sigh*

I'm sorry if i'm being hard on him, but it's just that those haters really make me mad. Where the fuck is the respect for others in this place?! Damn...

[inflated]

Originally Posted by chocomus

True! Those kind of comments are what make nice and good artist/writers leave the site. I get so mad at those kind of people... We're not here to judge anyone and i'm sure we can give our opinion without being rude or mean.

Where the fuck is the respect for others in this place?! Damn...

Sorry but certain things do not deserve respect or tolerance, incest is one of them as is pedophilia. Find a site for creeps, but this should not be the nature of this site. Trolling is what MG300 is doing and that is creepy. Not everything should be tolerated, so no certain writers do not deserve respect if they are creeps.

[benchdude]

Originally Posted by inflated

Sorry but certain things do not deserve respect or tolerance, incest is one of them as is pedophilia. Find a site for creeps, but this should not be the nature of this site. Trolling is what MG300 is doing and that is creepy. Not everything should be tolerated, so no certain writers do not deserve respect if they are creeps.

agreed. and it's interesting you grouped those 2 together, seeing as how musclegod posted how strongly he was against pedophilia in the Young Thugz story thread (he even used the same word "sick" that I used). plus let's not forget that he has also posted comments and stories about how cool it would be to have sex with your own dad as well as your brother. I happen to think it's hilarious that he thinks pedophilia is sick, but yet incest is perfectly acceptable.. lol give me a break. I would really love to see an intelligent explanation from him (or anyone) of how one of those is acceptable while the other isn't.

if I were to repost my original comment, I would probably leave out the part about "needing help", that didn't really need to be said, but everything else I would have done as is.

[trax29]

Originally Posted by benchdude

if I were to repost my original comment, I would probably leave out the part about "needing help", that didn't really need to be said, but everything else I would have done as is.

I'm glad to see you admit that those comments should be altered. I think what some of us are getting at Benchdude is, it's not the meaning of what you said that has offended some of us. In fact, like I've mentioned before, I think the idea is pretty gross in real life. It's that you chose to make obviously hateful remarks. Whether or not you truly intended for those comments to sound hateful is not clear.

I also like how several people have said what this "board" should be about... (ie. what is or is not acceptable material to post.) Clearly the lines are fuzzy over what material is or is not acceptable as this is a forum for fictional stories about muscle growth. I just hope we can all agree that hateful remarks have no place here. Just because you don't agree with a person's opinions (even if they sometime tend to contradict themselves) doesn't mean you should attack them.

Again Benchdude, thank you for admitting that your comments could have been worded better.

[thufirhawat]

Originally Posted by jsmith2300

Well, it's a tough call. On the one hand, brother-brother stories hit so close to home since I have a brother and can see where that attraction comes in sometimes (jealousy over size, etc). With Dad-son stories, I think the attraction comes in for me when a son outgrows his father and shows off. Kind of saying how his genetics are superior and showing how their roles have shifted in the son's favor. So, for me, that's hot. I say if you are looking to do one, go for it. We have a lot of brother stories. Son-father we don't see often. I'd just be careful with the sex is all.

--JSmith

I totally agree with Jsmith !

[MAZIVKAROLY]

Originally Posted by musclegod300

Just wondering how many of you are turned on by Dad on Son, Or Bro on Bro Stories.

OH, yeah, I know of a couple if real live father/son's who are combination bodybuilders and wrestlers. Would love to see more stories following this thematic.

[musclerodriguez]

[COLOR=gray]Anyone who knows me knows that I’m a huge fan of ‘father/husband muscle growth’ fiction. Give me a story where a dad or husband muscles up any day! Although I don’t require it, I don’t have any problems with reading about fathers and sons getting it on. Assuming of coarse that the son is an older teenager and near equal to his dad.[/COLOR]
[COLOR=#808080][/COLOR]

[COLOR=gray]I agree that in ‘real life’ incest is gross. I have no desire to get it on with my dad or older brother. But in fiction, especially on fantasy forums like this one, I’ve enjoyed reading about fictional dads and sons muscling up and hooking up. It’s fun, and if most guys are honest, hot![/COLOR]
[COLOR=#808080][/COLOR]

[COLOR=gray]One of my only dislikes about the muscle growth stories I’ve come across is that a lot of them center on young boys. That does make me uncomfortable, so when I come across a ‘great story’ that happens to be one of them I simply imagine that the boys are much older. I try to remember that the story is the authors personal vision, and may be perfect just the way it is to other readers. I advise any reader to do the same when reading about father/son intimacy. Just imagine that the dad is really ‘unrelated’ uncle Joe who likes to be called daddy. In your own mind, as you read it, tweak it to your level of comfort.[/COLOR]
[COLOR=#808080][/COLOR]

[COLOR=gray]I’m a big fan of Musclove, Texas and Mass-X by Max Mann, not to mention Hunter: D.I.L.F. by Ardvark2 where the school bully becomes Hunters dad. I would love to see more stories about dads muscling up on this site, and I don’t care either way if the father and son get it on. So musclegod300 don’t stop writing great father/son fiction because some people have a problem with it.[/COLOR]

[COLOR=gray]Your stories are great just the way they are and you have a devoted reader in me, so keep up the good work.[/COLOR]

[SoraIsTheMan]

I realy like Bro on Bro Stories. Wspecial sence I like RokuSo/SoRoku But I would really love to See a story of those two as Twin brothers and something or another casues them to grow

[giantw]

I must have missed this post.

I LOVE father-son stories, but only where the son outgrows and belittles the dad. They are my favorite. No son can be cruel, demeaning or dominant enough!

Brother-brother, could go either way. I would love to see a big brother, who is adored by his small younger bro, get even bigger and stronger, until the little bro worships him like a god. That would be a change of pace from the "lil bro" stories we have seen so far.

[soccerstud88]

Wow Havn't read this post for a while didn't even think it still was on the forum!

[Mad Dog]

I used to be against incest in muscle growth stories, but now... I've seen the light? {:3

[Aarrow]

Personally I don't have any problems with bro/bro incest, the stories are usually hot. Father/son, well, if it's done well..., but don't really prefer it over anything else.

[andy2011]

I think father/son stories are really hot, and if there's muscle growth, wrestling or various tests of strength it's even better!

[andy2011]

Regarding the "problem" with the incest theme, I only wish to say that this site (like many others on the Net) is based on erotic fantasies, and fantasies can go far beyond whatever one would/could do in real life.
You can like it or not, no one is forced to read what he doesn't like, but dad/son stories are a major turn-on for many people and I wish there were more on this site as well.

I also like brothers' stories, especially about twins who compare each other's "sizes" etc.

[bigdave]

There is a site called Peter's Stories that occasionally deals with themes of incest. The stories are extremely well written - so much so that they seem plausible and that much more distasteful. I can't cope very well with father-son stories, but bro on bro is quite exciting. After all older brothers sometimes need to help their younger brothers out.

[Shahrazad2]

This is an interesting topic, with a number of different components. Here's my take on it.

1. I don't have any brothers, just a sister, and I always kinda wanted one. I think even people who have brothers would like to feel closer and relate better with them, and the same wish goes for being closer to one's father as well. It's this wistful idea of "I'm a guy (and for those on this forum "and I'm into muscles") and I wish I had someone close to me to share these feelings with," and the obvious choice for someone to share those feelings would be a close male relative... like a father or brother.

2. While attraction of SOME sort does factor in to most of the stories on here, that attraction (particularly for the straight members of this forum, and the gay guys who are already in lasting romantic relationships) is primarily aesthetic (or at least not something that they would act on). As a number of the more unrealistic versions of muscle growth discussed are fantasies, there is some feeling of taboo situations conveyed, but this isn't an aspect of everyone's enjoyment of muscle. It is possible (even for the most oversexed gay man) to enjoy the view and presence of powerful muscles without even wanting to do anything with them, especially in the case of close friends and other people who aren't viewed as objects of attraction, just as objects of admiration.

3. For some reason, twins are always eye-catching. Twin brothers, especially where one or both are muscular, are especially hot (perhaps, based on #1, because who is closer to sharing your experiences and sensations than a twin, and perhaps because even fraternal twins tend to have similar features... for visual people, sex in front of mirrors can be intriguing as well, and identical twins or similar-looking fraternal twins tend to have a natural mirror effect between themselves).

4. Fathers are strong, towering, supportive figures to us when growing up, and if girls are said to settle down with men who are similar to their fathers (for good or bad), gay men could have the same effect. Someone who shares the qualities of a father could be seen as attractive for those reasons, even as someone who shares a brotherly relationship with you could be seen as attractive in a "closeness" manner.

5. The "daddy"/"papi" terms are confusing. On the one hand, they are a sign of masculinity and comfort/attractiveness. Similarly, referring to lovers as "boy" or "baby" or even "son" (though I noticed the last one more often years ago, when older men frequently referred to younger men or boys as "son" regardless of their heritage) also seems to imply a father-son connection. I think that these terms, while commonplace, add to the confusion.

6. It is possible to have a brotherly or fatherly relationship with someone, even if you aren't their brother or father... and it is possible for some of those personality traits to pop up in romantic relationships as well... a pair of gay men who are "closer than brothers" or a May-December romance where the older partner acts paternal to the younger one.

7. Despite what Freud would say, not everyone is attracted to/wants to kill their fathers. My dad is white-haired, slightly overweight, and has never inspired feelings of sexual attraction in me (even if white haired, slightly overweight tall guys do turn others of you on). I can't speak for anyone who does find attractive physical features in their father, but I can say that I love my dad for a number of other reasons, like his coolheadedness, intelligence, gentleness, and supportiveness, and while I would like to find someone with those same features for myself someday, I'm not looking to date my dad. I can understand how that might be different for others, and I have been with a couple guys who are fathers, and there is some appeal there (maybe because they're proven fertile and responsible and hardworking?) but in that case, it is easier to feel attractive to someone who IS a father, rather than someone who is YOUR father.

8. A number of stories seem to feature stepfathers (which does seem kinda freudian to me, as the stepfather is taken away from one's mother, but which, though a bit uncomfortable sounding, isn't strictly incestuous) or stepbrothers, and it seems that there is less of a stigma there.

9. I find pedophilia to be creepy and unattractive. Children under the age of 18, while perhaps sex-driven (especially in puberty) are not mentally and emotionally mature enough to attract me (and even anyone under 20 is still very young for me... I'm 27, and I'm currently finding guys my age more attractive than even the 21, 22 year olds I occasionally meet at bars). It doesn't matter if it's just sex or if it is a relationship, there is still a staggering difference in attitude and personality in those changing years. I can befriend them, but I have a harder time finding them attractive. Children below the legal age are not only illegal, they're not registering as potential sexual creatures, and they're less attractive to me. This might not be the case with everyone, but even one does find "boys" and the "boyish" look attractive (and some "boyish looking" guys my age can be extremely attractive), one needs to keep in mind that appearances don't equate a true (if only momentary or short-lived) connection between two people, even if they are attractive to each other. I think the traditions of Ancient Greek or Japanese pederasty are likewise uncomfortable, because they're not based on the modern concept of freedom and attraction and love, but by the idea of a transaction ("Service" from the younger in exchange for "training" from the elder) and a duty.

10. Brothers inspire envy, in the "I want what he has, we're brothers so we should be treated equally by mom and dad, and we should share the same physical features because of our genes" sense, and this is probably what appeals to those with muscle envy or an enjoyment or subverting power plays (with the large number of "Little Brother grows huge" stories out there), and older/bigger/more athletic brothers can be "powerful" bully-like figures, appealing to those who enjoy dom/sub situations. Younger brothers can throw tantrums or cause trouble for their older siblings (often) without meaning to, and there might be some wish-fulfilment there ("I wish that instead of babysitting an annoying kid keeping me from going out, I was hanging with a muscle stud who looked up to me... at least figuratively). Fathers, like big brothers, can also be bullies, though that area is profoundly uncomfortable for me, with a loving family situation growing up, and the horrific damage that a bullying father can cause to the psyche of a child. Fathers could also be gentle and supportive and loving, however, and that could appeal, with a father growing to massive size and muscle... especially if he could share his secrets for doing so.

11. Personally, I am more likely to enjoy a brothers story if there is support and attraction between the two, not bullying. I prefer it if the brothers in question are best friends as well as having some sort of attraction/admiration for each other's physiques. If they are stepbrothers or adopted, that's generally better, but really, their friendship means that they don't even have to be brothers in the first place for me. Fathers are trickier... while older/mature men are attractive, even an adoptive or stepfather figure has a lot of responsibility to raise and care for a child in an unsexual manner, and sex or attraction between a father and son is very difficult to stomach.

12. Age is important. I find that a lot of my complaints about father-son/brother-brother relationships fade when both people are full adults. A 28 year old son and his 53 year old father (or father figure), or two brothers in their 20s or 30s can be much more appealing than teenaged brothers/sons, because everyone is a consenting adult. They can act teenagerlike (say, if the method of muscle growth makes them act that way due to hormones flooding their system), but generally they have to be mature enough at the beginning.

[PianoBro]

any good muscle growth stories out there with the father-son meme?

[anpuZA]

Oooh well... whatever floats your boat. Fantasy is fine. Josman's Raunchy son (and other selection of Hand Job art) is incredibly sexy, because of the FANTASY sex and the quality of the illustrations. Seeing a dad and his son in real life enjoying that level of intimacy would indeed be very disturbing, but I can't say the same about two brothers, there are two gorgeously muscled twins doing the rounds here and on youtube and I will not complain if they get it on. Not to mention those 3 bro's who made it a while back in the gay porn industry.

Seriously, there are worse things in the world than that, child molesters and bestiality* freaks amongst other things. (I mean beastiality... like goats and moo-cows etc.)

[mutador]

Originally Posted by PianoBro

any good muscle growth stories out there with the father-son meme?

I wrote a few a while ago:
dad recovering authority
father's pinkie stronger than son's body
The super fireman
Joe turning back home

check them out if you want, search for them, I think they're still in this forum, if not, I can repost them.
There are great stories from other authors too, of course
I particularly liked one called "Always respect your daddy" or something like that, which is the story of a father who can absorb energy from other people